Review process
Review Process
Guidelines for the review of articles in the academic journal "Turystyka Kulturowa" ("Cultural Tourism")
Information for reviewers and authors, dated December 15, 2011
DESCRIPTION OF THE ARTICLE REVIEW PROCEDURE
The procedure described below is in accordance with the "Basic Principles for Reviewing Publications in Academic Journals," issued by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education in 2011.
1. Each submission is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers drawn from the journal’s permanent panel of reviewers. These reviewers are neither members of the journal’s editorial staff nor its Scientific Editorial Board; furthermore, for any given manuscript, they have no affiliation with the institution to which the author belongs.
2. Reviewers for articles intended for a specific issue of the journal are selected by the editor-in-chief (or their deputy) in consultation with the issue’s managing editor. In cases where the subject matter of a manuscript falls within a specific field for which the journal has a designated thematic editor (a member of the editorial team with a proven academic track record in that field), the reviewers are selected by that thematic editor in collaboration with the issue’s managing editor. 3. In cases justified by the subject matter of the research, its specific methodology, or the interdisciplinary nature of the text, the managing editor—in consultation with the thematic editor or the editor-in-chief—may request that one of the two reviews be conducted by a scholar specializing in the relevant field who holds at least a doctoral degree and is not a member of the journal’s permanent panel of reviewers. In such instances, the editorial team will first approach members of the journal’s Editorial Scientific Board to either provide a review or recommend a suitable reviewer.
4. For manuscripts written in a foreign language, at least one of the reviewers must be affiliated with an institution located in a country other than the author’s country of origin.
5. The author(s) of the manuscripts and the reviewers remain anonymous to one another (a "double-blind review process" is applied).
6. Reviews must be submitted in writing using a standardized review form (a sample form is provided below for the authors' information). The review process is completed by filling out an electronic form, which is accessible via the journal’s online portal—a platform available at all times to editorial staff and reviewers. Reviews are archived in electronic format. Reviewers are required to address every point in the form and must explicitly select one of the following recommendations: accept the article for publication, accept it subject to conditions, or reject it. 7. By publishing the review form provided below as part of this document, the Editorial Board fulfills its obligation to make it publicly available on the journal’s website.
8. The names of reviewers for individual publications or issues are not disclosed; however, the journal’s website—specifically the *impressum* (masthead) of each subsequent issue—provides a full, public list of the reviewers who collaborate with the journal as members of its permanent review panel.
9. The content of a completed review is not made public; it is shared exclusively with the author of the manuscript.
10. In accordance with the guidelines established by the editorial team of *Turystyka Kulturowa* (Cultural Tourism) for the issue editor, reviewers receive the full version of an article—as submitted by the author, following initial discussions and any preliminary revisions—no later than 40 days before the publication date. Reviewers are requested to complete their reviews within approximately 10 days. The issue editor then forwards the review to the author and ensures that any recommendations made by the reviewers are addressed. Once these revisions are incorporated, the editor performs a final proofreading of the article and includes it in the issue.